The Distinction Between Architecture and Sculpture 2

Wednesday, February 12th, 2014
liked this article
Assaabloy- 300 x 250 (expire Dec 31 2016) – NEW AD
contemporary architecture
FavoriteLoadingsave article

Architecture is not sculpture; it should be more than a visual form. However, contemporary buildings and ultra-modern architectural designs might be blurring the limits between these two art forms.

Unlike sculpture, architecture is a practical art, which means that it operates under a different group of limitations than sculpture, painting, poetry or dance.

Almost all architecture critics over the last two centuries have agreed that the interior space is the defining factor in architecture. Buildings need to facilitate the activities taking place inside them, such as office work, education, entertainment or government, while ensuring people’s comfort and safety, resisting and adapting to different weather conditions and preserving the natural and built environment.

Frank Gehry Guggenheim Museum Bilbao

Frank Gehry’s Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao, Spain (1997)

In looking at some modern building designs, however, it is hard to know whether architects are prioritizing the function or the form. Many projects are facing strong criticism, as was the case with Frank Gehry’s University of Technology Dr Chau Chak Wing Building, which is now under construction in Sydney.

Architects are being accused of trying to impose some overall “vision” that no one seems to understand in an attempt to stand out from the crowd. Great engineering complexity and additional dollars are required to make these unique and innovative designs work.

Some people have argued that these kind of buildings should be categorized as sculptures instead of architecture.

Frank Gehry’s silver building in Düsseldorf

Frank Gehry’s silver building in Düsseldorf.

While people’s appreciation of various types of architecture may vary, it is often easy to distinguish between what is architecture and what is just construction. Nobody doubts, for example, that a gothic chapel or a Venetian palace is an excellent and unquestionable example of architecture, while a great petrol tank of similar dimensions does not deserve such consideration.

In the same way, it should be possible to find values that allow us to distinguish between what is architecture, and what is more like a sculpture of huge dimensions. Architecture and sculpture are both three-dimensional arts, but sculpture has many characteristics that a piece of architecture does not share.

Traditionally, sculpture stands alone as a piece of art; it is not inhabited by human beings and no activity is intended to take place inside it. In addition, there are no human safety requirements for sculpture, which is typically not placed side by side with existing sculptures, often from different time periods.

Hotel Marques de Riscal

Hotel Marques de Riscal – A Luxury Collection Hotel in Elciego, Spain, designed by Frank Gehry.

Moreover, there are no systems for water, air, light, electricity and telecommunications inside a sculpture. Sculptures typically do not use energy and the resource efficiency of a sculpture is not determined by its form.

Italian Architect Bruno Zevi, one of the most important architecture critics of the 20th century, alluded to the differences between sculpture and architecture when writing about the Parthenon in his book Introduzione all’architettura.

“Those who investigate the Greek temple in an architectonical way, looking only for a space conception, will have to flee horrified, considering it as a typical example of not-architecture,” he wrote. “But those who approach the Parthenon and contemplate it as a great sculpture will stay admired as in front of the best works ever created by the human genius.”

As many would agree, this consideration of the Parthenon as not-architecture would fit many of the most celebrated structures of today, where the buildings’ showy exteriors turn them into modern temples.

Metro station in Riyadh by Zaha Hadid

Metro station in Riyadh by Zaha Hadid

In architecture, the emphasis should be placed on the importance of both exterior and interior design, creating a remarkable spatial experience for the user or visitor. Architecture also has to adapt to the natural and built environment in which it is inserted.

Architects can be artists and abstract thinkers, but what should set them apart is the ability to transform those concepts into something functional and real.

FavoriteLoadingsave article


 characters available
*Please refer to our comment policy before submitting
  1. Rajendera K. Kapoor P.E.

    It is interesting to see that how much money is wasted in Built Environment by Architects like Frank Gehry who has some sculptors and teaming structural engineers who want to be popular and make something different. It is OK to have so many windows in each wall and you can eve design a moving window or a glazing with changing shade, but putting 400 lamps or so many curvy stones add to comfort or better environment. I think the Guggenheim and such organizations boards feet should be held to ground, just because they keep increasing entry fees and restricting art's visit by few riches instead of opening it to masses by keeping costs low should be first priority for any organization dealing with art. Just leaving an exhibition hall open few hours a week does not count that, they do so for name sake; they need to keep every day prices low including parking, food, water and sale of prints. It should not be business as usual and patrons should raise voice. I have done so in places where I am patron, and request that all engineers, architects and patrons should be doing so across the world. Some of these things are so ridiculous and do not add to built environment and writer is correct in differentiating them as sculptor and not architecture that Gehry gets credit for which his lowly paid staff and engineering partners produce.

  2. leni

    interesting write-up, but I would like to point out 1. sculptures do not stand alone, they exist in an interactive relationship 2. human safety is an important requirement for the production of sculpture 3. sculptures eg. play forms could behave like buildings; they facilitate the activities that take place in and around them. Almost anything you can imagine in sculpture is possible in architecture and vice versa