The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) allows investors to choose between two methods of claiming depreciation on plant and equipment assets. These are the diminishing value and the prime cost methods of depreciation.
When an investor makes their depreciation claim, they can choose only one of these methods, so it’s important for them to understand how this choice will affect their investment returns.
Both the diminishing value and the prime cost methods claim the total depreciation value available over the life of a property. However, the two methods use different formulas to calculate depreciation deductions, achieving different short and long-term cash flow positions for the property investor.
Under the diminishing value method, the deduction is calculated as a percentage of the balance you have left to deduct. The formula a quantity surveyor will use to calculate depreciation using the diminishing value method is shown below.
Under the prime cost method, the deduction for each year is calculated as a percentage of the cost. The formula a quantity surveyor will use to determine the amount of depreciation deduction under the prime cost method is shown below.
The strategy of the individual investor must be considered when determining which method is the best choice for them.
If an investor makes their claim using the diminishing value method, they are claiming a greater proportion of the asset’s cost in the earlier years of the effective life of the asset as set by the ATO, therefore receiving greater deductions in the earlier years of owning the property. Alternatively, by selecting the prime cost method the investor is claiming a lower but more constant proportion of the available deductions over a longer period.
No matter what strategy an investor has, it’s recommended they seek advice from an accountant when making a decision.